The Dark Side of Kale: Is it ruining your metabolism?

Kale, if you haven’t noticed, has topped the list as one of America’s TOP health foods. Once a pretty garnish on the salad bar, it is now commonly found in supermarkets, farmer’s markets, health stores and restaurants. Raw, blended, roasted, stewed or sautéed, kale has made a huge claim in the veggie department and has some promising potential for protecting against cancer, among other health benefits.

Some have claimed it to be “the age of kale”. Even the President dined on kale salad at his Thanksgiving feast as noted in The Washington Post. With this craze, people are learning how to AMP up their kale intake by throwing massive amounts of kale, typically raw kale, into a blender with some other fruits and veggies and voila! they have breakfast– every, single, day. Let’s face it — it’s much easier to drink, rather than eat kale after all… and much faster too! In a face paced society why wouldn’t we reach for short cuts?

But is there trouble is this cruciferous paradise? Can too much of a good thing actually be not so good?

Like all things in the nutrition world the answer to this is, it depends.

Normal, reasonable amounts of kale should not be a problem for most people. A regular person (without thyroid issues) who eats several servings of crucifers per day should not be at any risk, especially if these greens are cooked (but more on that in a minute). This has been confirmed by professors of nutrition at the Harvard School of Public Health. Consuming large quantities of raw cruciferous vegetables (often the foundation of a green smoothie) can have a dark side, however. Green smoothies are an easy, and relatively new way of guzzling down huge quantities of greens like kale and may come with some unwanted side effects.

“It’s the dose that makes the poison” ~Dr. Teresa Fung, Harvard School of Public Health

Kale has a component called goitrogens, a substance that can contribute to enlarging your thyroid and limiting the function of your thyroid gland– in turn, lowers your metabolism. Sometimes it can contribute to the development of a goiter as well. For a population with ever increasing thyroid issues (especially women), this is not such a good thing. Cold hands and feet, intolerance to cold, hair loss, fatigue and decreased resistance to stress are all symptoms
of thyroid problems and a slower than normal metabolism.

In addition…

Kale and other greens (such as swiss chard, arugula, spinach, etc) are also loaded with oxalates, a compound that can promote kidney stones and severe pain in the body organs and tissues. There is still some controversy in the nutrition world as to whether limiting oxalates in the diet really matters, so oxalates are likely not a health concern unless you have a history or tendency to develop kidney stones.

Do not despair! There is still some good news. 

Certain nutrients and cooking methods can limit the goitrogenic effect of raw crucifers, such as kale. Read on for some tips:

  1. Iodine: For those of us that are health conscious (and even those who are not), there comes a natural avoidance of table salt which, under public policy, is fortified with iodine. Since goitrogens inhibit iodine intake and its action, it’s important to get enough. If you don’t use iodized table salt on a regular basis, you might consider using a multivitamin that contains some iodine or eating more foods that are rich in iodine like seaweed, kelp, fish, eggs and some dairy products. And, a special caution to pregnant and nursing mothers: iodine is absolutely CRITICAL to the growth of your fetus, so you may consider ditching those raw green smoothies while trying to conceive and during gestation and breastfeeding.
  2. Eat seaweed: Kale on it’s own is not going to give you a thyroid issue, but it could push you over the edge into a poor metabolic rate. As mentioned in #1, seaweed is a fantastic source of iodine and it can help you get what you need without resorting to the use of iodized salt. You can find seaweed at Asian food markets and selected grocery stores.
  3. Cook your kale: Goitrogens are greatly diminished by cooking, so it’s good advice to boil, roast or stew your kale before eating. This is the same for any other cruciferous veggie like broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, cauliflower, collards, kohlrabi, bok choy, etc.). Oxalates, on the other hand are not shown to be affected by cooking.
    Processed with VSCOcam with 5 preset
  4. Eat your kale with fat: Eating your veggies with fat increases the availability of fat-soluble vitamins D, E, A and K from the food source– a benefit you do not want to miss out on! Lightly sautéing or drizzling your crucifers with coconut oil, ghee, butter or extra-virgin olive oil are all nourishing ways to accomplish this task.
  5. Lastly, consider ditching the green smoothies and eating a normal, whole foods meal. Will a green smoothie kill you? No. But drinking one daily probably provides little benefit and may pose some risk. There is no current recommendation on the number of green smoothies you can have, but if you cannot live without them, I would limit it to 1-2/week max. If you need a quick fix, consider hard-boiled eggs, organic whole fat yogurt and nuts or made a veggie casserole ahead.

Remember, these recommendations are part of a comprehensive approach to total health. There is no magical food, no curative pill or perfect diet that will create perfect health. Drinking enough water, eating enough fiber, eating a variety of good fats and proteins, getting adequate sleep and exercising appropriately are other factors that will contribute to the lack or luster in your life.

Some raw kale, cabbage or broccoli is not going to ruin your metabolism or be a cause of major concern. It’s the dose that matters (as with many things in life), so it’s important to switch things up and do a little bit of everything.

When I think about anything in life, typically the old adage comes to mind, “all things in moderation”. We often get hyped up about specific nutrients and foods in the nutrition realm, but the key is moderation. Getting a large variety of vegetables, in this case, is much better for you than trying to focus on one nutrient or food– kale in this case.

Think about how our ancestors ate kale. They almost ALWAYS cooked it and most certainly consumed it with fat. There is wisdom in these traditional preparations of food and I think we should honor them…

100 years ago, it was not possible to kale a whole bunch of raw kale and pulverize it into tiny bits that were drinkable. And by that statement, I am not saying all juicing or blending has no advantages. I am just helping point out a truth that we have evolved to eat real food, but furthermore, in it’s true form. Sometimes cooked, sometimes raw, but nearly always in amounts that can be digested and consumed before blending.

Do you have favorite kale recipes or ideas for preparation? Please leave your comments below.

In Health and Vitality,


You May Also Like…

Overcoming Triggering People & Food

Overcoming Triggering People & Food

Co-Authors Tammy Lantz & Beth Basham You walk into your relative's house full of anticipation and excitement for the holiday only to be met with comments such as "Hi honey, looks like you've lost/gained weight!" or "Did you see your Aunt May? She's gotten huge!"...

4 Truths About Weight and Why You Struggle With It

For decades women (and men) have been bombarded with misinformation about how to lose weight and keep it off. Nutrition scientists and researchers have also tried to unravel the mystery of weight gain and loss and its impact on our overall health. It feels like every...

5 Truths About Mindfulness, Intuitive Eating, And Health.

5 Truths About Mindfulness, Intuitive Eating, And Health.

Over the course of the past 2 decades I have done it all... I have dieted, I have restricted, I have debated the value of butter and eggs, I have tried to be "perfect", I have hated my body and I have listened to everything and everyone else BESIDES my internal wisdom...